Toyota Tacoma Reliability by Year: Best & Worst

2020 Toyota Tacoma pickup — Toyota Tacoma reliability by year guide

By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 16 November 2026. Research-based on published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a Tacoma. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.

Toyota Tacoma reliability by year is a frame story before it is an engine story. The engines are famously durable — the question is what is happening underneath.

Toyota Tacoma Reliability by Year: The Shortlist

Complaint counts are NHTSA owner complaints per model year (MotorBiscuit), not adjusted for sales. A complaint is not a failure rate.

Year Published record Verdict
2013 93–125/yr Strong buy
2014 93–125/yr Strong buy
2015 93–125/yr Strong buy
2016 324; 63 shifting Avoid
2017 First-year faults carry over Avoid
2018 ~210–220 complaints Good, with checks
2019 ~210–220 complaints Good, with checks
2020 54–90/yr Strong buy
2021 54–90/yr Strong buy
2022 54–90/yr Strong buy
2023 54–90/yr Strong buy
2024 154; 49 transmission Avoid
2025 112 complaints so far Too new to score

Why Tacoma Reliability Comes Down to the Frame First

Most reliability guides start with engines. On a Tacoma, the frame comes first: between 2005 and 2010, frames in road-salt states rotted through — sometimes cracking near the motor mount — while the engine kept running fine (MotorBiscuit; RealTruck).

This guide is not a ranking. Our Most Reliable Pickup Trucks guide ranks the Tacoma 1st among midsize trucks, ahead of the Frontier 2nd and the Ridgeline 3rd, and Most Reliable Trucks puts it in the full-size context — this is the year-by-year record behind that ranking.

Tacoma Generations at a Glance: 1995 to the 2024 Redesign

Four generations cover the used market (249Auto; RealTruck). First (1995–2004): 2.4- and 2.7-litre fours and a 3.4-litre V6; frame rust peaked at 266 complaints for the 2001 (MotorBiscuit). Second (2005–2015): the 2.7-litre four and 4.0-litre V6 — the generation that built the Tacoma’s modern reputation and also produced its worst years. Third (2016–2023): the 3.5-litre V6, six-speed automatic and modern safety tech, with a rough first two years, then the model’s most reliable stretch. Fourth (2024–present): a turbocharged 2.4-litre four and a hybrid option, too new to judge.

The Frame Rust Problem: What Happened to 2005–2010 Trucks

The 2006 Tacoma drew 782 NHTSA complaints, the most of any Tacoma year, and about 300 of them mention the frame or rust. The 2005 drew 707, with about 280 about the frame (MotorBiscuit). Owners sued, claiming the frames were not properly protected against rust; in salt-belt states some rotted through entirely. RealTruck lists 2006, 2007 and 2009 among the worst Tacoma years on record. The 2006–2009 trucks also drew unintended-acceleration reports, linked to a sticky accelerator pedal (RealTruck), and 2009 trucks had a documented fuel pulsation dampener leak causing sputtering and power loss. Not every 2005–2010 Tacoma is bad — many lived in dry states — but judge each one on its underside, not its odometer.

Toyota’s Frame Settlement: What It Covered — and Why It No Longer Helps Buyers

Toyota settled a federal class action for up to $3.4 billion without admitting liability, covering 2005–2010 Tacomas, plus 2005–2008 Sequoias and 2007–2008 Tundras (MotorBiscuit, citing Automotive News). Under the settlement, Toyota inspected trucks for 12 years from first sale and replaced frames that failed its rust standard. That window has now closed for every truck in the settlement, so a rusty frame today is the buyer’s problem, not Toyota’s. A 2008 with a replaced frame and paperwork is a different truck from one with its original frame — no records means assume it is original.

The 4.0 V6 and 2.7 Four: The Engines That Built the Reputation

The second generation’s engines are the reason the Tacoma’s reputation survived its frame disaster. The 4.0-litre 1GR-FE V6 (236 hp, 266 lb-ft) and the 2.7-litre four (159 hp) are both well-regarded, and 249Auto calls them the engines that built the current reputation. Both use timing chains. 249Auto calls 2011–2015 the band with the fewest open questions, many trucks now well past 150,000 miles. The third generation replaced the 4.0 with a 3.5-litre V6 (278 hp) using the Atkinson cycle, keeping the 2.7 four as the base engine (249Auto). The 3.5 is solid once past its first two years. On any second- or third-generation truck, check lower ball joint history, differential and transfer case fluids, and a dry, clattery idle (249Auto).

The 2016–2017 Transmission Stumble: Hunting Gears and Harsh Shifts

The redesigned 2016 Tacoma arrived with the new 3.5-litre V6 and a six-speed automatic, and owners immediately complained about stiff shifters, delayed or hunting shifts and hesitation — 63 of the 2016’s 324 complaints were about shifting (MotorBiscuit). 249Auto calls the behaviour “a drive-it-before-you-buy-it issue”, not a reliability failure — the drivetrains hold together. There were also two recalls: 2016–2017 V6 trucks whose crankshaft position sensor could malfunction and stall the engine (17V-356, about 32,000 trucks) and 2016–2017 trucks that could leak oil from the rear differential (17V-285) (MotorBiscuit). Software updates followed, and by 2018 most first-year issues were resolved (RealTruck). The 2016 and 2017 stay on the avoid list, but the risk is checkable on a specific truck: drive it in stop-and-go traffic and on a hill, and confirm both recalls are closed.

The Best Tacoma Years to Buy: 2013–2015 and 2020–2023

The 2013–2015 trucks are the best of the second generation, with 93–125 NHTSA complaints a year, after the worst of the frame rust (MotorBiscuit). RealTruck calls 2013–2015 the second generation’s sweet spot; 249Auto puts its lowest-risk band at 2012–2015.

The 2020–2023 trucks are the best of all, drawing 54–90 complaints a year — the fewest of any Tacoma years (MotorBiscuit). Two caveats: on a 2022–2023, make sure the axle shaft recall is done (24V-152, about 381,000 trucks), and on some 2023s the steering column recall (23V-480 and 25V-040) (MotorBiscuit). The 2018–2019 trucks are solid too, at about 210–220 complaints each (brake recall 18V-888). The Tacoma also appears in our Best Used Cars to Buy guide and in Most Reliable Used Cars.

Three years are contested. On 2010, RealTruck lists it among recommended years, while MotorBiscuit includes it in the 2005–2010 frame-rust avoid band — treat 2010 as borderline: buy only with a clean underside. On 2012, RealTruck lists it among years to avoid (power loss, check engine light), while 249Auto puts 2012–2015 in its low-risk band — check carefully rather than avoiding outright. And one Knowledgementors piece calls the whole 2005–2015 second generation “excellent / buy with confidence” and even recommends 2005–2009 as best value. That contradicts the NHTSA record, so it is not used here.

The 2024 Redesign: Too New to Judge

The fourth-generation Tacoma switched to turbocharged four-cylinder and hybrid engines for 2024. It drew 154 complaints, up from 54 for the 2023, with 49 about the transmission — hard jerks, delayed shifts, power cutting out (MotorBiscuit). Recalls: rear brake hoses on 2024–2025 4x4s (25V-058, ~222,000 trucks); shock absorbers (26V-514, ~48,000). Powertrain: base SR 2.4 turbo, 228 hp / 243 lb-ft; i-FORCE, 278 hp / 317 lb-ft; i-FORCE MAX hybrid, 326 hp / 465 lb-ft (AutoGuide). A six-speed manual is still available on the i-FORCE engine; the hybrid is automatic-only; max towing 6,500 pounds. RealTruck is softer, calling 2024 a first-year redesign to monitor; this guide follows MotorBiscuit: avoid it for now. The 2025 has 112 complaints so far, 53 about snapping inside door handles, plus a driveshaft recall (25V-656) — too new to score. The 2026 has no NHTSA complaints or recalls yet (MotorBiscuit).

How Long Does a Tacoma Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?

A well-maintained Tacoma realistically reaches 200,000 to 300,000 miles (249Auto). iSeeCars’ September 2026 study of 395 million vehicles puts the Tacoma at a 26.7% chance of reaching 250,000 miles — the highest of any midsize pickup — with a 51.1% chance of 200,000 miles (RoadEthos, citing iSeeCars). The cost picture is more mixed. RepairPal rates the Tacoma 3.5 out of 5.0 and ranks it 7th of 7 midsize trucks, with an average annual repair cost of $478 — below the $548 midsize average and the $652 all-vehicle average — noting repairs are infrequent but severe when they happen. Consumer Reports, by contrast, gave the 2022 Tacoma 5/5 for reliability (via CarTipsDaily). RepairPal measures repair cost, frequency and severity; Consumer Reports measures how rarely things go wrong.

How to Inspect a Used Tacoma Frame Before You Pay

See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist; for a Tacoma, add these:

  1. Run the VIN through NHTSA’s recall lookup or Toyota’s owner site.
  2. Get under any 1995–2015 Tacoma and tap the frame rails. Flaking, soft or holed metal means walk away.
  3. Ask whether the frame was replaced under Toyota’s program on a 2005–2010 truck, and get the paperwork.
  4. Check where the truck spent its first years — a salt-belt title needs a harder look than a desert one.
  5. On a 2016–2017, drive it in stop-and-go traffic, and confirm recalls 17V-356 and 17V-285 are closed.
  6. On a 2022–2023, confirm the axle shaft recall (24V-152) is done; on a 2023, the steering column recalls too.
  7. On a 2024, check for jerky shifts, and look at the rear brake hoses and shocks on 4x4s (recalls 25V-058 and 26V-514).
  8. On a 2012 or newer truck, inspect the engine bay and undercarriage for chewed wiring — Toyota’s soy-based wire insulation from 2012 attracts rodents (RealTruck).
  9. Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic.

Tacoma Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most

What is the worst Toyota Tacoma year?

The 2006, with 782 complaints to NHTSA — the most of any Tacoma year, mostly about frame rust (MotorBiscuit).

Is frame rust a dealbreaker on a used Tacoma?

Only if it is structural: surface rust is cosmetic, but rust that has compromised the frame is often a dealbreaker (RealTruck).

Can I still get a free frame replacement from Toyota?

No — the settlement’s 12-year window has closed for every truck it covered (MotorBiscuit).

Is a 2016 or 2017 Tacoma worth buying at a discount?

Only with a test drive in stop-and-go traffic, both recalls closed, and a price that reflects the risk (249Auto).

Is the 2024 Tacoma reliable yet?

Not yet proven: a first-year redesign with elevated transmission complaints and two recalls; 2025 shows improvement, but both are too new to score.

Sources

Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Most Reliable Pickup Trucks, Most Reliable Trucks, Used Car Buying Guide, Best Used Cars to Buy, Most Reliable Used Cars.

Emily Turner SUV & Truck Reviewer

author
Emily Turner is the SUV & Truck Reviewer at My Car Reviews. She covers SUVs, crossovers, pickup trucks, and adventure-focused vehicles. Her reviews focus on space, towing, comfort, performance, and everyday usability. She helps buyers compare vehicles based on practical needs and overall value.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *