By Daniel Carter — Senior Automotive Editor. Published 18 November 2026. Research-based on published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a Silverado 1500. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 reliability by year is two engine stories and one transmission story: the 5.3 V8’s lifters fail across three generations, the 2021–2024 6.2L V8 is under recall and an open federal investigation, and the 8-speed shudders on 2015–2019 trucks.
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Reliability by Year: The Shortlist
Scores are AutoReliabilityIndex’s 0–100 index unless marked J.D. Power.
| Year | Published record | Verdict |
| 2013 | Last GMT900 year; AFM eased | Good, with checks |
| 2014 | 78/100 J.D. Power; launch year | Avoid |
| 2015 | 84/100 J.D. Power; best band | Good, with checks |
| 2016 | A/C leaks; 8-speed shudder | Inspect closely |
| 2017 | 79/100 J.D. Power | Strong buy |
| 2018 | 70/100 ARI; 551 complaints; 84/100 J.D. Power | Strong buy |
| 2019 | 64/100 ARI; 1,043 complaints; 20 recalls | Avoid |
| 2020 | 67/100 ARI; 693 complaints; 20 recalls | Good, with checks (5.3L) |
| 2021 | 67/100 ARI; 720 complaints; 13 recalls | Good, with checks (5.3L); avoid 6.2L |
| 2022 | 70/100 ARI; 514 complaints; 8 recalls | Strong buy |
| 2023 | 75/100 ARI; 299 complaints; 4 recalls | Strong buy |
| 2024 | 73/100 ARI; 367 complaints; 9 recalls | Good, with checks (5.3L); avoid 6.2L |
| 2025 | Under investigation for 6.2L | Too new to score |
How We Judge Silverado 1500 Reliability
Three kinds of evidence: the NHTSA record (complaints and recalls per model year, compiled by AutoReliabilityIndex), third-party scores (J.D. Power, RepairPal) and repair costs. MotorBiscuit names 2015–2018 the best band; other guides put 2014–2016 together as an avoid band. This guide follows the NHTSA record.
Silverado Generations at a Glance: GMT900, K2XX and T1XX
GMT900 (2007–2013): the 4.8 and 5.3 V8s with Active Fuel Management (AFM), plus the 4.3 V6 and 6.2 V8. K2XX (2014–2018): EcoTec3 engines with direct injection, the 6-speed, and the 8-speed from 2015. T1XX (2019–present): Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM) replacing AFM, the 2.7 turbo four, the 3.0 Duramax diesel, and the 10-speed.
Our Most Reliable Trucks guide covers the full-size segment; Most Reliable Pickup Trucks ranks the midsize field — Tacoma 1st, Frontier 2nd, Ridgeline 3rd.
The AFM Lifter Problem: Why 2007–2011 Trucks Burn Oil and Tick
Active Fuel Management shuts down four of the eight cylinders under light load, using collapsible hydraulic lifters. Worn, stuck or collapsed lifters make the engine tick and misfire, and can destroy the camshaft (MotorBiscuit). Over 12,000 NHTSA complaints have been filed for 5.3L lifter failures in Silverado 1500s (Knowledgementors).
The Gen IV 5.3, especially the LC9 in many 2010–2014 trucks, also burned oil: the piston rings let too much oil into the cylinders. In October 2022 a federal jury in California found GM hid the defect and awarded $102.6 million to about 38,000 owners and lessees who bought 2011–2014 vehicles with the LC9 (MotorBiscuit, citing Jalopnik). Lifter replacement costs $3,500–$8,000 (Knowledgementors); an AFM delete costs about $1,500–$2,500.
The 2014 Launch Year: Transmission Shudder, A/C Leaks and Electrical Faults
The 2014 redesign brought the K2XX platform and the Gen V EcoTec3 engines, and the highest engine-complaint count of any Silverado year on repair-tracking sites (OrganizerTone, citing CarComplaints). MotorBiscuit lists 2014 among the worst years. A/C condenser leaks were endemic on 2014–2016 trucks, and the 6-speed 6L80 could shudder under light acceleration after 40,000 miles (CarTipsDaily). J.D. Power gave the 2014 a 78/100 Quality & Reliability score (via Octane GMC).
The 8-Speed Automatic (2015–2019): Shudder, Harsh Shifts and Torque Converter Trouble
The 8-speed 8L90 arrived for 2015 and shuddered on 2015–2019 trucks. The cause was not broken gears but the torque converter clutch and the original factory-fill fluid: Dexron HP absorbed moisture, and the clutch’s stick-slip action felt like rumble strips at 45–55 mph (OrganizerTone; CarTipsDaily).
GM’s fix was Technical Service Bulletin 18-NA-355: a triple flush with Mobil 1 Synthetic LV ATF HP (blue label), after which the shudder usually clears within 200–500 miles. Driven with the shudder for thousands of miles, the clutch lining glazes permanently and the torque converter must be replaced (OrganizerTone). Trucks built from the 2020 model year left the factory with the revised fluid, so on any 2015–2019 truck ask whether TSB 18-NA-355 was done.
The 6.2L L87 Recall: 2021–2024 Connecting Rod and Crankshaft Defects
In April 2025 GM recalled about 597,600 US trucks and SUVs (NHTSA 25V-274; GM N252494000) with the 6.2L L87 V8 built 1 March 2021 to 31 May 2024, for connecting-rod and crankshaft defects (Rohnert Park Transmission; MotorBiscuit). The remedy is a dealer engine test: trucks that pass get 0W-40 oil, trucks that fail get a replacement engine.
The fix has not stopped every failure. On 20 August 2026 NHTSA opened Engineering Analysis EA26005, covering an estimated 997,743 L87 vehicles from model years 2021–2026. NHTSA cited 499 owner complaints of failure after the remedy, 191 failures in engines built after the recall window, and GM’s own report of 6,953 post-remedy failures (JobbersWorld, citing NHTSA). In September 2026 NHTSA cited 946 reports of L87 failure; GM’s response was due 30 October, extended to 13 November 2026 (Valero Law). The investigation was still open at the time of writing.
The Best Silverado Years to Buy: 2012, 2017–2018 and 2022+
The 2012 is the late-GMT900 pick: the last year of the old platform, with the AFM bugs of the late 2000s largely worked through, and J.D. Power’s highest Silverado reliability score at 86/100 (Haley Chevrolet, citing J.D. Power). One disagreement: a Knowledgementors AFM guide lists 2012–2013 as peak AFM failure years, while the same publisher’s longevity guide calls 2011–2013 the turning point, with 2012 the most dependable year. This guide follows the majority — MotorBiscuit, J.D. Power and the longevity record — and names 2012 a strong buy.
The 2017–2018 trucks are the strongest pre-T1 buy: quality peaked, lifter failures fell, and NHTSA complaint volume dropped (Knowledgementors). The 2018 scored 70/100 on AutoReliabilityIndex with 551 complaints and 16 recalls, and 84/100 on J.D. Power (Haley Chevrolet).
The 2022–2023 trucks are the newest safe picks: the 2022 refresh brought a revised 2.7 turbo (430 lb-ft, up from 348), and AutoReliabilityIndex scores the 2023 at 75/100 with 299 complaints and 4 recalls. The Silverado also appears in our Best Used Cars to Buy guide and in Most Reliable Used Cars.
The 5.3 V8 by Generation: Which Version to Trust
Gen III (1999–2007, LM7) has no cylinder deactivation — the simplest 5.3 (MotorBiscuit). Gen IV (2007–2014, LC9 and others) is the oil-burner: avoid 2010–2014 LC9 trucks unless records prove the oil issue was addressed. Gen V (2014–2018 L83, then 2019–present L84) moved the risk from oil to lifters: AFM on the L83, DFM on the L84 (MotorBiscuit).
Two safe harbours: the 4.3L V6 (285 hp), which has no AFM at all (AutoExpertsHub), and the 2020–2021 5.3L L84 (Knowledgementors). The 2021 needs one extra check: lifters built September 2020–March 2021 came from a faulty batch (CarTipsDaily).
The 2019 Launch Year and Dynamic Fuel Management
The 2019 is the T1 launch year and the weakest scored year on AutoReliabilityIndex: 64/100, with 1,043 complaints and 20 recalls. DFM replaced AFM, but lifter collapse remained frequent, and GM issued multiple bulletins (OrganizerTone). Owners reported lifter noise as early as 60,000 miles (Knowledgementors), The 2019 stays on the avoid list.
How Long Does a Silverado 1500 Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?
A maintained Silverado 1500 typically lasts 150,000–200,000 miles, some beyond 250,000 (MotorBiscuit). iSeeCars’ analysis of 402 million vehicles puts the Silverado 10th among all vehicles most likely to exceed 250,000 miles, at an 18.8% chance (Knowledgementors, citing iSeeCars).
RepairPal rates the Silverado 1500 3.5 out of 5.0, 5th out of 17 full-size trucks, at $714 a year against $936 for the segment (RepairPal). CoverageX budgets higher — 3.4/5 at $1,298 a year — pricing in the big-ticket failures rather than RepairPal’s invoice average (CoverageX, via the F-150 guide).
Silverado vs F-150 and Ram 1500: Which Full-Size Truck Holds Up Best?
On RepairPal’s numbers the three are tied at 3.5/5: the Ram ranks 1st of 17 at $691 a year, the Silverado 5th at $714, and the F-150 7th at $788 (RepairPal). CoverageX reverses the order on cost: Silverado $1,298, F-150 $1,345, Ram $1,456 a year, with the Tundra best at 4.0/5 and $987 (CoverageX). The two tables measure different things — invoice averages versus big-ticket failure budgets.
AutoReliabilityIndex scores the Silverado 73/100 overall, against 68/100 for the Ram 1500 and the F-150. But the headline studies split: J.D. Power’s 2026 dependability study ranked the Ram 1500 #1 in Large Light Duty Pickup, while Consumer Reports’ 2026 predicted-reliability scores put the Silverado at 40/100 against the Ram’s 5/100 (via the Ram 1500 guide). The year-by-year record in this guide is the tiebreaker.
Pre-Purchase Checklist: What to Inspect Before You Buy a Silverado 1500
See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist; for a Silverado add:
- Run the VIN through NHTSA’s recall lookup — especially 25V-274 on any 2021–2024 6.2L.
- Cold-start the V8: a tick that stays warm is lifters or cam.
- Check oil use on any 2007–2014 truck.
- On a 2015–2019, drive at 45–55 mph: shudder means the 8-speed needs TSB 18-NA-355, or a torque converter.
- On a 2014–2016, check the A/C condenser.
- On a 2019–2021, listen for lifter noise.
- On a 2021, check the lifter build window (September 2020–March 2021).
- On a 6.2L, demand proof of the 25V-274 engine test.
- Get an independent pre-purchase inspection.
Silverado 1500 Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most
Which Silverado 1500 year is the best overall buy?
The 2023 is the best recent pick; 2018 is the value sweet spot and 2012 the best older truck.
Is the AFM lifter problem fixable, or should I avoid those years?
It is fixable — $3,500–$8,000 for lifters, or a $1,500–$2,500 AFM delete — but buy only with records.
Is a 2021–2024 6.2L Silverado safe now that the recall is done?
Not proven: NHTSA’s EA26005 investigation is still open after 499 post-remedy failure complaints.
Does the 8-speed shudder mean the transmission is dying?
Not necessarily — the TSB 18-NA-355 fluid flush fixes most cases, but a glazed torque converter needs replacement.
Is the 4.3L V6 a good buy?
Yes, if the towing suits you: no AFM, no lifter issue, and usually cheaper than an equivalent V8.
Sources
- MotorBiscuit: How many miles will a Chevrolet Silverado 1500 last? — https://www.motorbiscuit.com/how-many-miles-will-a-chevrolet-silverado-1500-last/
- MotorBiscuit: GM 5.3 V8 Problems: Oil Consumption, Lifters and Years to Avoid — https://www.motorbiscuit.com/gm-5-3-v8-engine-problems/
- MotorBiscuit: GM’s 6.2L V8 Recall Fix May Not Have Worked as NHTSA Investigates More Failures — https://www.motorbiscuit.com/gms-6-2l-v8-recall-fix-may-not-have-worked-as-nhtsa-investigates-more-failures/
- Rohnert Park Transmission: GM 6.2 Engine Recall (25V-274) — https://rohnertparktransmission.com/blog/gm-6-2-engine-recall-25v274
- NHTSA: Recalls and complaints by model year; Engineering Analysis EA26005 — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- AutoReliabilityIndex: Chevrolet Silverado Reliability by Year (2024 model page; vs Ram 1500; vs Ford F-150) — https://autoreliabilityindex.com/chevrolet/silverado/2024
- RepairPal: Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Reliability Rating — https://repairpal.com/reliability/chevrolet/silverado-1500
- GM Authority: 2022 Chevy Silverado 2.7L Turbo Engine Gets Big Torque Boost — https://gmauthority.com/blog/2021/09/2022-chevy-silverado-2-7l-turbo-engine-gets-big-torque-boost/
- GM Authority: Here Are The Refreshed 2022 Chevy Silverado 1500 Specs — https://gmauthority.com/blog/2021/11/here-are-the-refreshed-2022-chevy-silverado-1500-specs/
- Knowledgementors: Everything to Know About Chevy Silverado AFM Engines and Lifter Problems — https://knowledgementors.com/m-auto/afs/default/rsoc/014e216a-aa48-4ae8-a4bb-f486d5f7ce8e/everything-to-know-about-chevy-silverado-afm-engines-and-lifter-problems?channel=Ch_31922
- Knowledgementors: Silverado Years to Avoid: The Lifter Problem That Actually Kills Engines — https://knowledgementors.com/m-auto/afs/default/rsoc/767e2161-4d85-4c55-a96b-f63d0b2ba0d2/silverado-years-to-avoid-the-lifter-problem-that-actually-kills-engines?channel=Ch_13151
- OrganizerTone: Chevy Silverado Engine Problems: The Specific Years and Engines to Avoid — https://organizertone.com/en/chevy-silverado-engine-problems-the-specific-years-and-engines-to-avoid-8388705/
- OrganizerTone: GM 8L90 Transmission Shudder: Affected Years, Causes, and Solutions — https://organizertone.com/en/gm-8l90-transmission-shudder-affected-years-causes-and-solutions-1513625/
- CarTipsDaily: GM 5.3 AFM Years to Avoid: What Every Truck Owner Should Know — https://cartipsdaily.com/5-3-afm-years-to-avoid
- CarTipsDaily: Chevy 5.3 Engine Problems: What Every Owner Needs to Know Before It’s Too Late — https://cartipsdaily.com/chevy-5-3-engine-problems-2026
- AutoExpertsHub: Chevy Silverado Years to Avoid: Used Buyer Guide 2026 — https://autoexpertshub.com/chevy-silverado-years-to-avoid/
- JobbersWorld: NHTSA Expands GM L87 Probe as 0W-40 Remedy Faces Tighter Base-Oil Market — https://jobbersworld.com/2026/08/25/nhtsa-expands-gm-l87-probe-as-0w-40-remedy-faces-a-tighter-base-oil-market/
- Valero Law: GM 6.2L V8 Engine Investigation Expands | November 2026 NHTSA Deadline — https://www.valerolaw.com/news/2026/9/23/1mxsh1jsp1sgf4v2ay1fabq4zkbi8c-6kbxy
Author: Daniel Carter — Senior Automotive Editor, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Most Reliable Trucks, Most Reliable Pickup Trucks, Used Car Buying Guide, Best Used Cars to Buy, Most Reliable Used Cars.
