By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 11 November 2026. Research-based: published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a CX-5. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.
Mazda CX-5 reliability by year is unusually consistent for a compact SUV — with one sharp exception. The 2016 model is the worst CX-5 year on record (CarComplaints, via MotorRank Media and CarBuzz), while the 2020–2023 cars are the consensus best buys.
Mazda CX-5 Reliability by Year: The Shortlist
The table gives a J.D. Power score only where a named source publishes one for that exact year; complaint counts are not failure rates.
| Year | Published record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | ~60 complaints (CarComplaints); 2.0L only | Good, with checks |
| 2014 | 123 complaints, 2nd-worst; 82/100 (CarBuzz) | Inspect closely |
| 2015 | Approach carefully (CarsCounsel); no score found | Good, with checks |
| 2016 | Worst year, 183 complaints; 74/100 J.D. Power (CarBuzz) | Avoid |
| 2017 | Best Older Choice (CarsCounsel); not rated | Strong buy (older) |
| 2018 | 83/100 (CarBuzz); fuel-pump, PCM recalls | Good, with inspection |
| 2019 | 81/100 J.D. Power (CarBuzz); turbo arrives; recalls | Good, with inspection |
| 2020 | 85/100 (CarBuzz); least-troubled; no recalls | Strong buy |
| 2021 | 82/100 J.D. Power (CarBuzz); no recalls | Strong buy |
| 2022 | 86/100 (CarBuzz); best overall; standard AWD | Strong buy |
| 2023 | 82/100 J.D. Power (CarBuzz); no recalls | Strong buy |
| 2024 | 82/100 (CarBuzz); best late-gen | Strong buy (newer) |
| 2025 | 82/100 (CarBuzz); too new to judge | Too new to score |
Two warnings. The 2022 score: the plan listed it as 82/100, but the verified figure is 86/100 (CarBuzz; MotorRank Media agrees). And 2015 and 2018–2019 are disputed (REREV vs CarsCounsel).
How the Two CX-5 Generations Compare for Long-Term Ownership
The first generation (2013–2016, KE) launched Mazda’s Skyactiv powertrain and proved mechanically robust, according to CarsCounsel — but early cars struggled with electrical gremlins, fragile windshields and rapid brake wear. CarBuzz averages the first generation at 78/100 on J.D. Power Quality & Reliability, against 82/100 for the second generation. The 2.0-litre (155 hp) was the only engine in 2013; the 2.5-litre (184 hp) arrived for 2014, both with Mazda’s six-speed automatic, which CarsCounsel says has no recognised pattern of widespread transmission failure. The second generation (2017–2025, KF) is the more reliable of the two, according to CarBuzz, with fewer recalls overall. A redesigned third-generation CX-5 arrived for 2026 (CarBuzz).
Best CX-5 Years to Buy: Why 2020–2023 Lead the Pack
CarsCounsel names 2020–2023 its Best Choice and calls 2022 the best overall. CarBuzz narrows the sweet spot to 2020–2021, calling 2020 the least-troubled CX-5 year going back five-plus years. MotorRank Media widens the window to 2018–2025, with 2022–2025 strongest. Every source puts 2020–2023 in the best band, so this guide presents 2020–2023 as the consensus best buy and notes MotorRank’s wider window. What makes these years strong is what they do not have: MotorRank Media reports no NHTSA recall campaigns for 2020–2022 or 2023–2025, and CarBuzz notes the 2020 and 2021 cars had zero recalls at the time of its May 2025 comparison. For the best value, buy 2020–2022; for a newer car, 2023–2024.
The 2017 Redesign: What Changed — and What It Fixed
The 2017 redesign is the dividing line in CX-5 reliability. CarsCounsel calls 2017 its Best Older Choice: the redesign brought a premium interior and replaced the laggy touchscreen with a physical command dial, which “drastically reduced electrical complaints.” CarBuzz disagrees, advising buyers to skip 2017–2018 as early second-generation years “still working out the kinks.” Buy a 2017 for the lower price and the proven 2.5-litre without cylinder deactivation, and check the infotainment and brakes. One recall to check: 17V744000, covering only 2017 cars fitted with the accessory trailer-hitch harness (MotorRank Media).
Years to Avoid: The 2016 LED Headlight Problem Explained
Avoid the 2016 CX-5. CarsCounsel says to avoid it “due to widespread electrical component failures,” and CarComplaints rates it the worst CX-5 year, with 183 complaints, according to MotorRank Media and CarBuzz. The most severe issue is the LED daytime running lights burning out prematurely. Because the LEDs are sealed into the headlamp unit, the whole assembly has to be replaced — $800–$1,500 (CarsCounsel) or about $1,000+ around 45,000 miles (MotorRank Media). NHTSA recall 20V063000 covers 36,761 US cars: a faulty sealing gasket released sulfur gas that corroded the LED circuit (Mazda). Only 2016 cars with factory LED running lights are covered — Grand Touring and Touring models with the Technology Package (OrganizerTone). Dealers replace the gasket or assemblies free of charge (Mazda 4320A). Consider a 2016 only if the recall is confirmed done on the VIN.
The Other Early Weak Spot: 2014 and First-Generation Wear
The 2014 CX-5 is the second-worst year on CarComplaints, with 123 complaints, according to MotorRank Media. Three problems repeat: windshields that crack easily (onset 20,000–30,000 miles, $500–$800); premature rear brake wear, RepairPal’s most commonly reported CX-5 problem (onset 25,000–40,000 miles, $300–$500 per axle); and infotainment glitches on 2016–2017 units (all MotorRank Media). The 2013 car is the quieter first-generation year, with roughly 60 complaints (MotorRank Media), and REREV names it the best first-generation year. Every 2013–2016 car also needs two recall checks: fuel-filler-pipe 16V064000 (2014–2016) and liftgate-strut 16V644000 (2013–2016).
Fuel-Pump and PCM Recalls on 2018–2019 Models: What to Verify
The 2018 and 2019 CX-5s carry two recalls a buyer must confirm. The first is the low-pressure fuel pump: NHTSA campaign 21V875000, issued in November 2021. The Denso pump’s impeller can crack and deform, starving the engine of fuel and causing a stall (NHTSA). The campaign covers 121,038 Mazdas, of which 81,830 are CX-5s (72,554 from 2018, 9,276 from 2019). Dealers replace the pump free of charge (Mazda 5321K). The second is the powertrain control module: NHTSA campaign 19V497000, covering 2018–2019 CX-5s, Mazda6s and 2019 Mazda3s with the cylinder-deactivation engine. Faulty software could let an intake rocker arm move out of position, causing a misfire or stall (NHTSA). Mazda recalled more than 260,000 vehicles for it; the remedy is a free PCM update (Mazda 3719F). Verify both on the VIN.
Turbo and Diesel CX-5s: Extra Checks Before You Buy
The turbocharged 2.5-litre Skyactiv-G arrived for the 2019 model year, with 227 hp (250 on premium), according to CarBuzz. Three reported problems belong on a buyer’s checklist: cracked cylinder heads on 2019–2021 cars, where thermal cracks let coolant disappear with no puddle (What Breaks; Mazda bulletin 01-013/21); Mazda’s CSP11 programme, extending cover to 10 years or 120,000 miles (What Breaks); and premature oil loss on 2021 turbos (bulletin 01-011/22, OrganizerTone). Check coolant and oil levels. The diesel barely existed in the US: the 2.2-litre Skyactiv-D came for the 2019 model year only, on the Signature trim, at about $41,000 (CarBuzz), and Mazda dropped it after 2020 (MotorTrend). It made 168 hp and 290 lb-ft, rated 27/30/28 mpg (Green Car Reports). Outside the US the reported problems are oil dilution, DPF clogging and camshaft wear (What Breaks, Carify).
How Long Does a CX-5 Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?
No CX-5-specific figure exists for reaching 250,000 miles — the iSeeCars 2025 study publishes only a Mazda brand figure of 3.6% (MotorRank Media). Owner communities report trouble-free ownership well past 100,000–150,000 miles, with a good number pushing toward 200,000 (MotorRank Media). Treat 200,000 miles as possible with strict servicing, not as an average. Running costs are where the CX-5 is strongest: RepairPal rates it 4.5 out of 5.0, 1st out of 26 midsize SUVs, at $447 a year — against $573 for the average midsize SUV and $652 for all vehicles. Owners average 0.3 unscheduled repair visits a year, and only 8% of repairs are severe, against 12% for all vehicles. The CX-5 also appears in our Best Used SUVs guide.
CX-5 vs RAV4 and CR-V: Which Compact SUV Holds Up Best?
The CX-5’s rivals are the cars in our Toyota RAV4 Reliability and Honda CR-V Reliability guides, and the comparison depends on which score you trust. On J.D. Power, Autoblog’s table puts the CX-5 ahead of the fifth-generation RAV4 on average — 82.9 against 78.8 — though the RAV4 won 2022, 87 against 86. CarBuzz names the CX-5 the most reliable compact SUV of the last decade on J.D. Power scores (ten-year average 82). Consumer Reports reverses it: the RAV4 scores 80 against the CX-5’s 72 (Autoblog), and the J.D. Power 2026 dependability study ranks Toyota 8th and Mazda 15th. Against the CR-V it is closer: J.D. Power gives the 2022 CX-5 86 against 82 (MotorBiscuit), but RepairPal rates both 4.5 out of 5.0. Summary: the CX-5 has the best J.D. Power record of the three, the RAV4 the better Consumer Reports score. The size contrast with larger SUVs is in Best Used Midsize SUVs.
What to Inspect on Any Used CX-5 Before You Pay
See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist. For a CX-5, add these checks:
- Daytime running lights on a 2014–2016 car: check for flickering; confirm recall 20V063 on the VIN.
- Windshield and brakes on a 2013–2016 car: check for cracks and pad wear.
- Recalls on a 2018–2019 car: confirm 21V875 and 19V497 are closed on the VIN.
- Coolant and oil on a 2019–2021 turbo: falling coolant with no puddle, or oil loss between services, needs a specialist look.
- Cylinder deactivation on a 2018–2021 2.5-litre: confirm the PCM update was done.
- Infotainment on a 2016–2017 car: test the screen and dial for freezing.
- Diesel records on a 2019 Signature: full history and a specialist inspection.
CX-5 Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most
Is the 2020 CX-5 really the best year to buy?
85/100 from J.D. Power, the least-troubled year going back five-plus years (CarBuzz), and no recalls on file.
Should I avoid every 2016 CX-5?
As a blind buy, yes — the worst year on CarComplaints, with a repair that can cost $800–$1,500. Consider one only if recall 20V063 is confirmed done.
Is a 2018 or 2019 CX-5 safe once the recalls are done?
Yes, with the VIN check — both recalls are free dealer repairs.
Does the turbo engine make a CX-5 less reliable?
Not as a whole — but check for cylinder-head cracks on 2019–2021 cars and oil loss on 2021 turbos.
Is the 2025 CX-5 a safe used buy?
Too early to judge. Its 82/100 J.D. Power score is an early-ownership score, and CarsCounsel calls 2025 too new to judge.
Sources
- CarsCounsel: Best and Worst Mazda CX-5 Years — https://carscounsel.com/mazda-cx-5-years-to-avoid/
- MotorRank Media: Mazda CX-5 Reliability: Common Problems, Best Years & Repair Risk — https://motorrankmedia.com/reliability/mazda-cx-5
- CarBuzz: The Most Reliable Model Year Mazda CX-5 To Buy If You Don’t Have $30,000 For A New One — https://carbuzz.com/most-reliable-model-year-used-mazda-cx-5/
- CarBuzz: Mazda CX-5 Generations Ranked By Reliability — https://carbuzz.com/mazda-cx-5-ranked-by-reliability/
- CarBuzz: The Most Reliable Compact SUV From The Last Decade Is A Familiar Face — https://carbuzz.com/mazda-cx5-most-reliable-compact-suv-the-last-decade/
- CarBuzz: What Makes The Mazda CX-5 A Reliability King In The Compact Crossover Segment — https://carbuzz.com/what-makes-mazda-cx-5-reliability-king/
- RepairPal: Mazda CX-5 Reliability Rating — https://repairpal.com/reliability/mazda/cx-5
- NHTSA: Recall 20V063000, LED daytime running lights (2016 CX-5) — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- Consumer Reports: Mazda CX-5 Recall for Daytime Running Light Failure — https://www.consumerreports.org/car-recalls-defects/mazda-cx-5-recalled-daytime-running-light-failure/
- Mazda North American Operations: Statement on Recall of Certain 2016 CX-5 Vehicles — https://news.mazdausa.com/2020-02-10-STATEMENT-ON-RECALL-OF-CERTAIN-2016-CX-5-VEHICLES
- NHTSA: Recall 21V875000, low-pressure fuel pump (2018–2019 CX-5) — https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/rcl/2021/RCLRPT-21V875-1378.PDF
- NHTSA: Recall 19V497000, PCM software / cylinder deactivation (2018–2019 CX-5) — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- NHTSA: Recall 16V064000, fuel filler pipe (2014–2016 CX-5) — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- Autoblog: Mazda CX-5 Vs. Toyota RAV4 Reliability: Close, But One Has The Edge — https://www.autoblog.com/features/mazda-cx-5-vs-toyota-rav4-reliability
- MotorBiscuit: Is The Honda CR-V More Reliable Than The Toyota RAV4?; 2023 Honda CR-V vs Toyota RAV4 — https://www.motorbiscuit.com/which-is-more-reliable-honda-cr-v-or-toyota-rav4/
- CarBuzz: Mazda’s Skyactiv-D 2.2-Liter Inline-Four Is The Highest-Revving Diesel Engine — https://carbuzz.com/mazda-cx-5-has-highest-revving-diesel-engine/
- MotorTrend: Mazda Abandons Its Diesel Plans in the United States — https://www.motortrend.com/news/mazda-6-cx-5-diesel-dead
- Green Car Reports: Mazda diesel has already come and gone — https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1132730_mazda-diesel-has-already-come-and-gone-here-s-why-it-didn-t-work-for-the-us
- OrganizerTone: Mazda CX-5 Engine Problems; Mazda CX-5 Daytime Running Light Recall — https://organizertone.com/
- What Breaks: Mazda CX-5 KF — All Engines, Problems & Buying Guide (2017–2024) — https://what-breaks.com/mazda/cx-5-kf
- Carify: Mazda CX-5 Common Problems — https://www.carify.com.au/mazda/cx-5/problems
- REREV: Best and worst Mazda CX-5 years — which to avoid — https://rerev.com/years-to-avoid/vehicles/mazda-cx-5/
- CarComplaints: Mazda CX-5 complaints by year (via MotorRank Media and CarBuzz) — https://www.carcomplaints.com/Mazda/CX-5/
- J.D. Power: CX-5 Quality & Reliability scores by year (via CarBuzz and MotorRank Media) — https://www.jdpower.com/cars/mazda/cx-5
Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Best Used SUVs, Best Used Midsize SUVs, Used Car Buying Guide, Toyota RAV4 Reliability, Honda CR-V Reliability.
