By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 21 November 2026. Research-based on published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a Crosstrek. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.
Subaru Crosstrek reliability by year is a story of two datasets that refuse to agree: one guide calls 2019–2023 the best window, while the complaint record calls 2019 the worst recent year.
Subaru Crosstrek Reliability by Year: The Shortlist
Scores are AutoReliabilityIndex (0–100); counts are NHTSA complaints, not failure rates. *2013–2015 filed as XV Crosstrek.
| Year | Published record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | 98 complaints (NHTSA*) | Avoid |
| 2014 | 107 complaints (NHTSA*) | Avoid |
| 2015 | 100 complaints (NHTSA*) | Approach carefully |
| 2016 | 133 complaints; 81/100 J.D. Power | Good with checks |
| 2017 | 98 complaints | Good with checks |
| 2018 | 60/100; 194 complaints; 5 recalls | Inspect closely |
| 2019 | 56/100; 279 complaints; 7 recalls | Avoid |
| 2020 | 72/100; 68 complaints | Good (value pick) |
| 2021 | 67/100; 108 complaints | Review carefully |
| 2022 | 78/100; 28 complaints | Strong buy |
| 2023 | 81/100; 28 complaints | Strong buy |
| 2024 | 69/100; 104 complaints; 2 recalls | Review carefully |
| 2025 | 83/100; 25 complaints; 0 recalls | Too new to score |
How the Three Crosstrek Generations Compare
The Crosstrek arrived in North America for 2013 as the XV Crosstrek — the “XV” was dropped for 2016 — a lifted Impreza hatchback with standard all-wheel drive and 8.7 inches of ground clearance (CarSpotty; RoadEthos). Generations: 2013–2017 on the old Impreza platform; 2018–2023 on the Subaru Global Platform; 2024–present, the third generation (CarsCounsel; CarSpotty). First years carry the most complaints; late years are the safest buys. Our Best Used SUVs guide lists the Crosstrek as a subcompact option; the Best Used Midsize SUVs comparison is a class contrast only.
Best Crosstrek Years to Buy: 2022–2023 and the 2.5L Upgrade
The 2022 is the best used buy: 28 complaints and no recalls, the cleanest recent record (RoadEthos). The 2023 matches it; AutoReliabilityIndex picks it as its best year at 81/100 (AutoReliabilityIndex). The engine changed the story in 2021, when the optional 2.5-litre arrived on Sport and Limited trims: 182 hp and 176 lb-ft, against 152 hp and 145 lb-ft for the 2.0-litre (Subaru). That 30 hp gain answered the oldest Crosstrek complaint; the 2.5-litre cars are the ones to seek in 2021–2023. The 2.5-litre debuted on the 2019 Forester but did not reach the Crosstrek until 2021 (Subaru). Any guide crediting it to 2019 Crosstreks has the year wrong.
The 2020 Value Pick: Clean Record at a Lower Price
The 2020 is the value pick: 68 complaints and 72 out of 100 on RoadEthos’s index, typically over $20,000 used (RoadEthos). AutoReliabilityIndex scores it the same 72/100; Consumer Reports rates it more reliable than other cars from its model year (CarSpotty). One counting difference: RoadEthos reports no recalls for the 2020, while AutoReliabilityIndex counts one. Buy the 2020 if the 2022–2023 cars are out of budget.
Years to Avoid: 2013–2014 Oil Consumption and Early CVT Trouble
Avoid 2013 and 2014 outright: CarsCounsel calls them out for “severe engine oil consumption and early continuously variable transmission defects” (CarsCounsel). The early 2.0-litre FB20 burned oil because its piston rings clogged; owners reported a quart every 1,000 to 1,500 miles (CarsCounsel; OrganizerTone). The early Lineartronic CVT shuddered and stalled, and the 2013 carries the highest transmission complaint volume of any Crosstrek year (CarsCounsel; OrganizerTone).
Subaru’s 2016 oil-consumption settlement (Yaeger v. Subaru of America) extended the powertrain warranty on affected 2013–2015 engines to 8 years or 100,000 miles (Top Class Actions; OrganizerTone). That cover has now expired, so the oil test is the buyer’s job. CVT cover was also extended to 10 years or 100,000 miles for 2013–2018 models (16-107-17R, OrganizerTone). Subaru revised the piston rings midway through 2015 production, and 2016-onward cars rarely report abnormal oil burning (OrganizerTone).
The 2018–2019 Problem Years: Windshields, Batteries, and Recalls
The 2019 is the worst recent year by every complaint-based measure: 279 complaints and seven recalls (RoadEthos), 284 and seven (CarSpotty), 272 with eight recalls and 56/100 on AutoReliabilityIndex — “the weakest of nine Crosstrek years” (RoadEthos; CarSpotty; AutoReliabilityIndex). The 2018 is next, with 194 complaints and five recalls (RoadEthos; CarSpotty).
The signature fault is the windshield: cracking with little or no impact is the top Crosstrek complaint across 2018–2026 (AutoReliabilityIndex). On the 2019, visibility and wiper reports account for 113 of CarSpotty’s 284 complaints, median mileage about 10,542 miles (CarSpotty). CarsCounsel blames thinner glass, fitted to save weight and fuel (CarsCounsel). Replacement is expensive: the windshield carries the EyeSight cameras, and one dealer quote reached $1,400 (AutoReliabilityIndex).
Two assumptions are wrong. The Powell v. Subaru windshield settlement (April 2025, eight years or 100,000 miles) does not cover the Crosstrek — its class is the 2019–2022 Ascent and Forester and the 2020–2022 Legacy and Outback (Powell, D.N.J. 2024). And the big brake-light-switch recall covered 2013–2017 Crosstreks — 363,566 in the US, of 1,303,530 US vehicles and about 2.3 million worldwide — not 2018–2019 cars (Subaru/NHTSA, via AboutLawsuits). The 2018–2019 recalls were the PCV valve (19V744, up to 83,499 Crosstreks), the ECM fault (19V743) and the rear stabiliser bracket bolts (21V263) (CarSpotty; CarSmite). Battery drain, with owners blaming the Starlink module, rounds out the 2019 fault list (AutoReliabilityIndex).
The 2019 paradox is this guide’s centrepiece disagreement: CarsCounsel calls 2019–2023 its Best Choice, crediting the 2.5-litre (CarsCounsel) — but the 2.5-litre did not reach the Crosstrek until 2021, so the window rests partly on an engine the 2019 never had, and the complaint data says the 2019 is the worst recent year, not the best. Buyer rule: 2022–2023 are the safe late-generation picks; a 2019 is only worth considering with every recall confirmed done on the VIN.
The 2021 and 2024 Question: Complaint Counts vs Consumer Reports
Neither the 2021 nor the 2024 deserves a blanket avoid. The 2021 drew 108 complaints (RoadEthos) and carries the inhibitor-switch recall, covering about 95,830 vehicles, where a weak weld could let water in and disable the reverse lights and camera (CarSpotty). RoadEthos also links a fuel-pump recall to the 2021, while AutoReliabilityIndex counts two recalls against CarSpotty’s one — the sources differ, so verify by VIN. Yet Consumer Reports rates the 2021 more reliable than other cars from its model year (CarSpotty).
The 2024, the first year of the third generation, drew 104 complaints and two recalls — an instrument-panel harness that could short and cut drive power, and front driveshafts that could crack (RoadEthos; CarSpotty). Yet Consumer Reports rates the 2024 “much more reliable than other 2024 vehicles” (CarSpotty). The split is a methods difference: NHTSA counts raw reports; Consumer Reports surveys owners on problems that needed repair. Verdict: review carefully, not avoid — and the 2025, with 25 complaints and no recalls so far, is too new to score (AutoReliabilityIndex).
Crosstrek Engines Compared: 2.0L, 2.5L, and the Hybrid
The 2.0-litre FB20, standard from 2013 through 2020 and on Base and Premium trims after that, makes 152 hp and 145 lb-ft (Subaru). It is adequate and, from 2016 onward, reliable — but slow. The 2.5-litre FB25D, standard on the 2021–2023 Sport and Limited, makes 182 hp and 176 lb-ft and is the engine to seek (Subaru). Every Crosstrek uses a Lineartronic CVT, except 2.0-litre cars with the six-speed manual through 2023 (Subaru; CarGurus). The hybrid is a footnote: a mild hybrid joined for 2014 (160 hp, 30 mpg combined — CarGurus), a plug-in hybrid followed for 2019–2023, and a new 2.5-litre hybrid arrived for 2026, too new to judge.
Used Crosstrek Pre-Purchase Checklist and Final Verdict
Our Used Car Buying Guide covers the full checklist; for a Crosstrek, add these:
- Run the VIN through NHTSA’s recall lookup — essential on 2018, 2019, 2021 and 2024 cars, and confirm the brake-light-switch recall on any 2013–2017 car.
- Inspect the windshield in bright light for chips and cracks, and check the EyeSight cameras were recalibrated.
- On a 2013–2015 car, run an oil-consumption test: a quart every 1,000–1,500 miles is the warning sign.
- Test the CVT from cold: shudder, stalling or a flashing AT OIL TEMP light is a walk-away sign.
- On a 2018–2019 car, check the battery: a car that goes flat after a few days parked may have the Starlink drain fault.
- On a 2021, confirm the inhibitor-switch recall is done and the reverse lights and camera work.
- Check the badge: the 2.5-litre is worth seeking from 2021 onward.
- Get an independent pre-purchase inspection.
Verdict: buy a 2022 or 2023, preferably a Sport or Limited with the 2.5-litre — 28 complaints, no recalls, and an 81/100 reliability score (RoadEthos; AutoReliabilityIndex). Buy a 2020 if the budget is tighter. Avoid the 2013–2014 cars outright, treat the 2019 as a car to inspect rather than a “best” buy, and check the windshield on every Crosstrek.
Crosstrek vs. RAV4 vs. CR-V: Repair Costs and Longevity
On RepairPal’s numbers the Crosstrek leads its class on rating but costs more to run: 4.5 out of 5.0, first of 26 compact SUVs, at $492 a year, against a $521 average (RepairPal, via AutoReliabilityIndex). The Toyota RAV4 Reliability hub shows the RAV4 at 4.0 out of 5.0, third of 26, at $429 a year; the Honda CR-V Reliability hub shows the CR-V at 4.5 out of 5.0, second of 26, at $407 a year.
Subaru Crosstrek Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most
Which Crosstrek year should I buy first?
The 2022, then the 2023: both have 28 complaints and no recalls; AutoReliabilityIndex scores the 2023 at 81/100, its best Crosstrek year.
Is the 2019 Crosstrek really that bad?
On complaint evidence, yes — 279 complaints and seven recalls, the most of any recent year, led by windshields. CarsCounsel still calls 2019–2023 its best window, but that rests partly on the 2.5-litre, which arrived only in 2021.
Do Crosstrek windshields really crack on their own?
Owners report cracks with no impact, sometimes on nearly new cars — the 2019’s visibility complaints had a median mileage of about 10,542 miles (CarSpotty). The Powell settlement does not cover the Crosstrek.
Is the 2.5-litre Crosstrek worth seeking out?
Yes — 182 hp against 152 hp for the 2.0-litre, standard on the 2021–2023 Sport and Limited (Subaru).
Should I avoid a 2021 or 2024 Crosstrek?
No — review carefully instead. Both carry heavier complaint loads, but Consumer Reports rates both above average for their model years (CarSpotty).
Sources
- CarsCounsel: Best and Worst Subaru Crosstrek Years — https://carscounsel.com/subaru-crosstrek-years-to-avoid/
- RoadEthos: What’s the Best Year for a Used Subaru Crosstrek? We Checked the Data — https://roadethos.com/car-buying/whats-the-best-year-for-a-used-subaru-crosstrek-we-checked-the-data
- CarSpotty: Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid: 2018, 2019, 2021 & More — https://carspotty.com/subaru-crosstrek-years-to-avoid/
- AutoReliabilityIndex: Subaru Crosstrek Reliability by Year — https://autoreliabilityindex.com/subaru/crosstrek
- CarSmite: Best & Worst Subaru Crosstrek Years [Backed By Data] — https://www.carsmite.com/best-worst-years-subaru-crosstrek/
- Subaru of America: 2021 Crosstrek Debuts With Refreshed Design, Suspension and an Available 2.5 Liter Engine (press release, 9 June 2020) — https://media.subaru.com/newsrelease.do?id=1639&mid=292&allImage=1
- NHTSA: Recalls and complaints by model year; brake-lamp switch recall WUE-90 (19V149) — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- J.D. Power: Crosstrek Quality & Reliability scores by year (via Huffines Subaru Corinth) — https://www.huffinessubarucorinth.com/blog/is-the-subaru-crosstrek-reliable-owner-reviews-ratings-and-faqs/
- Consumer Reports: Crosstrek reliability ratings by model year (via CarSpotty) — https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/subaru/crosstrek/
- RepairPal: Crosstrek reliability rating and annual repair cost (via AutoReliabilityIndex) — https://repairpal.com/reliability/subaru/crosstrek
- Top Class Actions: Subaru Oil Burning Class Action Settlement (Yaeger v. Subaru of America) — https://topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/closed-settlements/subaru-oil-burning-class-action-settlement/comment-page-5/
- OrganizerTone: Subaru Crosstrek FB20 Oil Consumption: Affected Years, Causes, and Fixes — https://organizertone.com/en/subaru-crosstrek-fb20-oil-consumption-affected-years-causes-and-fixes-1882055/
- OrganizerTone: Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid: CVT Problems and Buyer Guide — https://organizertone.com/en/subaru-crosstrek-years-to-avoid-cvt-problems-and-buyer-guide-1600740/
- Powell v. Subaru of America, Inc., No. 1:19-cv-19114 (D.N.J. 2024) — https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-jersey/njdce/1:2019cv19114/419228/155/
- CarGurus: Subaru Crosstrek Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy — https://www.cargurus.com/research/articles/subaru-crosstrek-buying-guide
- iSeeCars: Crosstrek lifespan estimate (via CarSpotty) — https://www.iseecars.com/cars-for-sale
- AboutLawsuits: Subaru Brake Light Problems Lead To Recall of 1.3 Million Vehicles — https://www.aboutlawsuits.com/subaru-brake-light-recall-154670/
Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Best Used SUVs, Best Used Midsize SUVs, Used Car Buying Guide, Toyota RAV4 Reliability, Honda CR-V Reliability.
