Subaru Forester Reliability by Year: Best & Worst

2021 Subaru Forester SUV — Subaru Forester reliability by year guide

By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 12 November 2026. Research-based: published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a Forester. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.

Subaru Forester reliability by year is the hardest call in this series: one guide calls 2015–2018 a best choice; another rates the whole fourth generation as the worst, with no best year in it. This guide shows both sides and gives a conditional buyer rule.

Subaru Forester Reliability by Year: The Shortlist

Scores appear only where a source publishes one.

Year Published record Verdict
2013 FB25 oil risk Good, with checks
2014 CVT stalling, oil use Avoid
2015 Most SJ-gen complaints; disputed Avoid
2016 Oil use fixed; 85/100 J.D. Power Good, with caution
2017 CarsCounsel best value; REREV worst Good, with conditions
2018 85/100 J.D. Power; REREV worst Good, with conditions
2019 Windshield, battery, TCV faults Inspect closely
2020 REREV worst; J.D. Power 83–84 Good, with inspection
2021 83/100 J.D. Power; REREV best Strong buy
2022 84/100 J.D. Power; REREV best pick Strong buy
2023 84/100 J.D. Power Strong buy
2024 83/100 J.D. Power; FB25 DI Strong buy
2025 6th-gen redesign; too new Too new to score

Warning: the 2015–2018 verdicts are disputed — the table follows the stricter side — and no 2025 score is given.

Read This First: Why Sources Disagree Sharply on 2015–2018

CarsCounsel calls 2015–2018 a “Best Choice”, praising the revised FB25 and sorted CVT, and names the 2017 the best overall value. REREV rates the whole fourth generation (2014–2018) as worst, with no best year in it, and lists 2015 and 2018 among the worst years to avoid. They weigh different evidence: CarsCounsel weighs the revised engine and value; REREV weighs NHTSA complaint volumes — every fourth-generation year drew 400 or more complaints, with 2015 and 2017 the worst. OrganizerTone sides with REREV on 2015; TheHealthyAttitude calls 2017–2018 the sweet spot but 2014–2015 avoid. Buyer rule: a 2017–2018 is defensible only with documented CVT warranty work and an oil check; a 2015 is not defensible on CarsCounsel alone.

Best Forester Years to Buy: 2019–2024 and 2021–2022 in Particular

The sources agree on the late fifth generation. CarsCounsel names 2019–2024 its Best Late-Generation Choice, crediting the Subaru Global Platform and the updated FB25 and CVT. REREV is narrower: its best years are 2021 and 2022, calling the 2022 the best pick, with the 2021 close behind — the 2021 had far fewer complaints than 2019 and 2020. J.D. Power agrees: 83/100 for 2021, 84/100 for 2022 and 2023, 83/100 for 2024 (SlashGear; CarBuzz). Buy 2021–2022 for the strongest record. REREV lists 2019 and 2020 among the worst years.

The 2015–2018 Question: What CarsCounsel Gets Right — and What It Misses

CarsCounsel’s case is not baseless. By 2015 the FB25’s worst oil years were behind it, the CVT had years of tuning, and the fourth generation is its most practical used generation. A 2017 is cheap, well equipped with EyeSight, and its best overall value. What CarsCounsel misses is the complaint record: every fourth-generation year drew over 400 NHTSA complaints, with 2015 and 2017 the worst (REREV). OrganizerTone agrees the 2015 carries double risk — valve-body faults and oil consumption together. The 2017’s own record is mixed too: a weak battery, freezing infotainment, and a transmission fluid-starvation fault (REREV). Verdict: 2016 with caution, 2017–2018 with conditions, 2015 avoided.

The CVT Problem on 2014–2018 Foresters: Valve Body, Solenoid P2764, and the 10-Year Warranty

The Forester’s signature fault is the Lineartronic CVT on the 2014–2018 cars: the TR580 with the 2.5-litre FB25, and the heavy-duty TR690 with the turbocharged 2.0XT (OrganizerTone). The most common failure is the torque-converter lock-up duty solenoid inside the valve body; when it fails it sets code P2764 and lights up the dashboard — the flashing AT OIL TEMP light plus Check Engine and other warnings, the “Christmas tree effect” (OrganizerTone). Failures typically surface between 80,000 and 120,000 miles. The 2014–2015 cars were worst, with repair costs of $3,000–$7,000 (TheHealthyAttitude); OrganizerTone puts a dealer valve-body replacement at $1,400–$2,200, a single-solenoid fix at $600–$950, and a complete CVT replacement at $6,500–$8,500. Subaru extended CVT cover to 10 years or 100,000 miles for 2010–2018 models (OrganizerTone), but it runs from the in-service date, so 2015 cover has largely expired.

Oil Consumption on the Early FB25 Engine (2011–2015)

The FB25 arrived for 2011, replacing the EJ25 and promising to end the head-gasket era — but created a different problem. The 2011–2015 Foresters began consuming oil at alarming rates: Subaru’s specification allowed up to 1 litre per 2,000 kilometres before calling it excessive, and owners reported far worse, a quart every 500–1,000 miles (TheHealthyAttitude). Defective piston rings were the cause, and a class-action settlement forced Subaru to extend the engine warranty to 8 years / 160,000 kilometres — but only if owners documented the problem early (TheHealthyAttitude). Verify cover by VIN. The repair costs $1,000–$2,000 (TheHealthyAttitude). The fix arrived in 2016, the first year without meaningful oil consumption. A 2011–2015 car is only worth considering with service records proving the oil issue was fixed under warranty.

Years to Avoid Outright: 1998–2002 Head Gaskets and 2014–2015

Two avoid bands, from two eras. The first is 1998–2002, where the EJ25’s single-layer head gasket fails catastrophically — coolant and oil leaking into the combustion chamber, a warped head and engine failure (CarsCounsel; TheHealthyAttitude). The repair runs $2,427–$3,190 (TheHealthyAttitude). The EJ25 stayed prone to external leaks through 2011, so the 2003–2011 cars need a head-gasket check too (CarsCounsel). The second band is 2014–2015, the worst of the modern era: the 2014 brought gearbox, suspension, oil and engine problems, and the 2015 inherited both the engine and transmission problems (REREV). TheHealthyAttitude is blunt: avoid 2014–2015 unless you can verify CVT warranty extension, and skip 2011–2015 unless service records prove the oil issue was addressed.

Fifth Generation (2019–2024): Windshield Cracks, Battery Drain, and TCV Faults

The fifth generation, on the Subaru Global Platform from 2019, is the most reliable overall — but its debut year was not clean. The 2019 suffered spontaneous windshield cracking, often in cold weather; replacement exceeded $1,000 because the windshield integrates the EyeSight cameras (TheHealthyAttitude). The same year brought battery drain, EyeSight glitches, and transmission control valve (TCV) failures at $500–$1,200 (TheHealthyAttitude). REREV lists 2019 and 2020 among the worst years and says to skip them. The pattern improves quickly: the 2021 was considered the best fifth-generation Subaru by industry experts (REREV).

The 2017–2018 Sweet Spot — With Conditions Attached

If the budget does not stretch to a 2021 or later car, 2017–2018 is the defensible older buy. TheHealthyAttitude calls 2017–2018 the sweet spot: by then Subaru had resolved the oil and CVT valve-body issues, and the cars offer EyeSight and modern infotainment. But the ‘eliminated the problem’ claim is disputed: OrganizerTone notes the TR580 can still suffer solenoid failures past 90,000 miles in 2017–2018, and REREV lists both years among its worst. Rule: buy a 2017–2018 only with documented valve-body or CVT warranty work, a 30,000-to-40,000-mile CVT fluid history, and an oil check — and prefer the manual, where it exists (OrganizerTone).

How Long Does a Forester Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?

A well-maintained Forester frequently surpasses 200,000 miles (CarsCounsel); TheHealthyAttitude puts the range at 200,000–300,000 miles — but the year you choose decides whether that journey is smooth or a financial catastrophe. No Forester-specific figure exists for the chance of reaching 250,000 miles, so none is given here. Running costs are middling: RepairPal rates the Forester 3.5 out of 5.0, ranking it 21st out of 26 compact SUVs, with an average annual repair cost of $632 — against $521 for the average compact SUV and $652 for all vehicles. The Forester also appears in our Best Used SUVs guide.

Forester vs RAV4 and CR-V: Which Compact SUV Holds Up Best?

The Forester’s rivals are the cars in our Toyota RAV4 Reliability and Honda CR-V Reliability guides, and on the headline numbers the Forester trails both. RepairPal rates the Forester 3.5 out of 5.0, 21st of 26 compact SUVs, against the RAV4 at 4.0, 3rd of 26, at $429 a year (RepairPal). The RAV4’s advantage is narrow in the year-by-year record: its best years are 2013 and 2016 at 85/100, the same score as the Forester’s best years (2016 and 2018, both 85/100). What separates them is the bad years: the RAV4’s worst year, 2019, scores 66/100, while the Forester’s 2014–2015 carry $3,000–$7,000 faults. The Forester’s counter is standard symmetrical all-wheel drive on every year. The size contrast is in Best Used Midsize SUVs — the Forester is a compact SUV, not a midsize.

Used Forester Pre-Purchase Checklist and Final Verdict

See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist. For a Forester, add these checks:

  1. Oil history on 2011–2015 cars: dipstick cold, records, short-block proof.
  2. CVT behaviour on 2014–2018 cars: engagement within 1.5 seconds, no shudder or stalling; scan for P2764 (OrganizerTone).
  3. CVT fluid on 2014–2018 cars: fresh fluid every 30,000–50,000 miles, valve-body proof.
  4. CVT warranty status: confirm the 10-year / 100,000-mile extension by VIN.
  5. Head gasket on 1998–2011 cars: check the lower block for weeping.
  6. Windshield and battery on 2019–2020 cars: cracks, drain issues, TCV repair.
  7. Recalls: search the VIN at NHTSA, including the 2009–2013 seat-belt assemblies.

Final verdict: buy a 2021–2024 Forester, ideally a 2022. A 2017–2018 is defensible only with the records above. Avoid 1998–2002 and 2014–2015 outright.

Forester Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most

Is a 2015 Forester a good buy if CarsCounsel calls it a best choice?

Not on that alone — REREV and OrganizerTone both rate the 2015 among the worst.

Which Forester year is the single best pick?

The 2022 — REREV’s best pick, 84/100 from J.D. Power, with the 2021 close behind at 83/100.

Does every 2014–2018 Forester need a new transmission?

No — the common failure is the valve-body solenoid, a $1,400–$2,200 dealer repair, often fixed under warranty. Verify it by VIN.

How much oil burning is too much on an early FB25?

Subaru’s own threshold was 1 litre per 2,000 kilometres; owners reported a quart every 500–1,000 miles.

Is the 2025 Forester reliable?

Too early to judge — it is a sixth-generation redesign, and CarsCounsel says to wait for long-term data.

Sources

Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Best Used SUVs, Best Used Midsize SUVs, Used Car Buying Guide, Toyota RAV4 Reliability, Honda CR-V Reliability.

Emily Turner SUV & Truck Reviewer

author
Emily Turner is the SUV & Truck Reviewer at My Car Reviews. She covers SUVs, crossovers, pickup trucks, and adventure-focused vehicles. Her reviews focus on space, towing, comfort, performance, and everyday usability. She helps buyers compare vehicles based on practical needs and overall value.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *