By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 13 November 2026. Research-based: published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own an Outback. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.
Subaru Outback reliability by year is the strangest call in this series: 2019 is both the most complained-about Outback on record and a best buy in the expert guides. This guide explains the paradox instead of picking one side.
Subaru Outback Reliability by Year: The Shortlist
Scores appear only where a source publishes one for that exact year. J.D. Power figures are from CarBuzz; ARI is AutoReliabilityIndex’s own index.
| Year | Published record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | FB25 oil use; CVT shudder | Avoid |
| 2014 | FB25 oil use; CVT faults | Avoid |
| 2015 | First 5th gen; worst 5th-gen year | Inspect closely |
| 2016 | 5th-gen apex; CR best year | Strong buy |
| 2017 | Apex year; battery drain | Strong buy |
| 2018 | ARI 64/100, 779 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2019 | 80/100; ARI 63/100, 1,017 complaints | Strong buy |
| 2020 | 71/100; ARI 60/100, weakest | Avoid |
| 2021 | 71/100; ARI 69/100 | Good, with checks |
| 2022 | 71/100; ARI 67/100 | Good, with checks |
| 2023 | 79/100; ARI 77/100 | Strong buy |
| 2024 | 79/100; ARI 82/100, 0 recalls | Strong buy |
| 2025 | ARI 82/100, 0 recalls; too new | Too new to score |
Warnings: the 2020 score is contested (one source claims 85/100; CarBuzz and TheHealthyAttitude both give 71 — this guide uses 71). 2022’s figure differs between CarBuzz pages (71 vs 74); this guide uses the October 2026 figure. No 2025 score is given (79 vs 81).
Read This First: The 2019 Paradox — Most Complaints, Best Buy?
The 2019 drew 1,017 NHTSA owner complaints, the most of any Outback year (AutoReliabilityIndex), and that site tells buyers to “steer clear of 2019 and 2020”. Yet CarsCounsel names 2018–2019 its best choice, and TheHealthyAttitude calls the 2019 “one of the smartest used purchases available”. Complaints are dominated by electrical and visibility reports — dead batteries, delaminating screens and cracking windshields — while the powertrain was mature and the two fuel-pump recalls (175,968 and 188,207 units, CarBuzz) were fixed free. Buyer rule: a 2019 is a strong buy only if the fuel-pump recalls are confirmed done on the VIN.
How the Outback’s Six Generations Break Down
Six generations through 2025: 1995–1999, 2000–2004, 2005–2009, 2010–2014 (BR), 2015–2019 (BS) and 2020–2025 (BT). The 2026 starts a seventh generation that drops the wagon body for a crossover SUV (CarBuzz). KnowledgeMentors states the pattern plainly: avoid first-model-year redesigns (2010, 2015, 2020) and unproven new engines (2013–2014 with the FB25). The safest bets are the 2012 3.6R, 2016–2017 and 2021–2025.
Best Outback Years to Buy: 2018–2019 and the 2021–2024 Recovery
CarsCounsel names 2018–2019 its Best Choice: “a mature platform with sorted electronics and reliable powertrains”. KnowledgeMentors adds a second apex, 2016–2017, and a third window, 2021–2025, once the sixth-generation bugs were fixed. The numbers support the late window best: AutoReliabilityIndex scores the 2024 at 82/100 with no recalls and 69 complaints, its best-scoring Outback year. CarBuzz groups 2023–2025 at 79/100, against 71 for 2021–2022. Buy 2023–2024 for the strongest record; 2016–2019 for the best value.
The 3.6R Six-Cylinder: Why Enthusiasts Hunt for It
The 3.6-litre flat-six (EZ36), offered through 2019, is the engine enthusiasts hunt for: 256 hp and 247 lb-ft (Torque News; Subaru’s 2019 specifications), against 175 hp and 174 lb-ft from the 2.5-litre four of the same year. It tows 2,700 lb, and KnowledgeMentors calls it “considered exceptionally reliable”. The sweet spot is the 2012 3.6 H-6 with the five-speed automatic, in a generation otherwise best avoided (KnowledgeMentors). The trade-offs are fuel economy (20/27 mpg, per Torque News) and age: the newest 3.6R is now seven years old.
The 2.5-litre FB25 four is the volume engine: 173 hp in 2013, 175 hp from 2015–2019, then 182 hp from 2020 (Torque News). Its record is split by year: the 2013–2014 piston-ring cars burn oil, the 2015–2019 cars are sound if the rings were fixed, and the 2020-onward engine shows no such pattern. The 2.4-litre turbo (260 hp, 277 lb-ft) is the strongest engine and the best tower at 3,500 lb, but it arrived in the weakest model year — start a turbo buy at 2021. All three use a Lineartronic CVT except the 2010–2014 3.6R’s five-speed automatic.
Years to Avoid: 2013–2014 Oil Consumption and CVT Failure
Avoid the 2013 and 2014 Outbacks: CarsCounsel says avoid them “due to severe engine oil consumption and widespread CVT transmission failures”. The cause was the early FB25’s defective piston rings, plus the Lineartronic CVT’s shuddering and premature failure (CarsCounsel; KnowledgeMentors). Subaru faced a class-action settlement in 2016, extending warranty coverage from five years or 60,000 miles to eight years or 100,000 miles (KnowledgeMentors) — but that cover has now expired on every 2013–2014 car. One outlier disagrees: CarLifespanCheck lists 2013–2014 among the best years to buy. This guide follows the CarsCounsel and NHTSA-complaint consensus instead: the piston-ring and CVT evidence is documented in the settlement and the complaint record.
The Early Fourth Generation: 2010–2012 Recalls and Head Gaskets
The fourth generation’s first three years are the recall record-holders. The 2010 Outback holds the record at 18 recalls — more than any other Outback year — and 2011 and 2012 follow with 16 each (TheHealthyAttitude). Many 2010 recalls are Takata airbag duplicates, but the Subaru-specific problems are worse: head gasket leaks around 100,000 miles, excessive oil consumption, and transmission troubles costing $3,000–$5,000 to repair outside warranty (TheHealthyAttitude). The head gasket is the defining issue of the EJ25 era, typically failing around 80,000–120,000 miles; the 2005–2009 cars carry the same risk. The exception is the 2012 with the 3.6-litre six and five-speed automatic (KnowledgeMentors) — the only 2010–2012 Outback worth considering.
The 2018 Battery-Drain and Windshield Problem — and Why 2019 Is Different
The 2018 concentrated the fifth generation’s electrical faults. The battery drain was typically caused by the Starlink Data Communication Module failing to enter sleep mode (KnowledgeMentors). The touchscreen delaminated, causing “ghost-touch” inputs (KnowledgeMentors). And windshields cracked spontaneously, sometimes with no impact (AutoReliabilityIndex). These faults produced a class-action settlement in 2022 (In re Subaru Battery Drain) covering 2015–2020 Outbacks — but a used buyer today should assume the settlement window has passed and verify the fixes on the car. The Powell v. Subaru windshield settlement (final approval April 2025) covers 2020–2022 Outbacks with an eight-year / 100,000-mile windshield warranty and a one-time replacement, including EyeSight recalibration. Note the scope: 2015–2019 windshield cracks were widely reported but are not covered by that settlement.
First-Year Sixth Generation: Why 2020 Needs Extra Scrutiny
The 2020 is the sixth generation’s first year, and every source treats it as the weakest. It carries six recalls (TheHealthyAttitude): a drive chain that can break and cause complete loss of power (198,255 units), a fuel-pump failure (175,968 units), and loose brake pedal bracket bolts (3,467 units). J.D. Power gives it 71/100 (CarBuzz; TheHealthyAttitude); AutoReliabilityIndex scores it 60/100, the weakest it scores, with 884 complaints. Owners reported the same DCM battery drain as 2018, plus delaminating infotainment screens, a rearview camera recall in December 2020, and CVT roughness on acceleration (TheHealthyAttitude). CarBuzz calls the 2020 “the most unreliable model year of the lot”. Skip 2020 entirely and start a sixth-generation search at 2021 (TheHealthyAttitude; KnowledgeMentors).
How Long Does an Outback Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?
A well-maintained Outback routinely reaches 200,000 to 300,000 miles (TheHealthyAttitude). iSeeCars’ analysis of over 300 million vehicles puts the average Outback lifespan at 177,828 miles, about 15.3 years, with a 33.8% chance of 200,000 miles and 22.3% of 250,000 (iSeeCars; Torque News). RepairPal rates the Outback 3.5 out of 5.0, 10th out of 26 midsize SUVs, at $607 a year, against $573 for the average midsize SUV (RepairPal). The Outback also appears in our Best Used SUVs guide.
Outback vs RAV4 and CR-V: Which Holds Up Best?
The Outback’s rivals are the cars in our Toyota RAV4 Reliability and Honda CR-V Reliability guides, and on the headline numbers the Outback trails both. RepairPal rates the Outback 3.5/5.0, 10th of 26 midsize SUVs at $607 a year, the RAV4 4.0/5.0, 3rd of 26 at $429, and the CR-V 4.5/5.0, 2nd of 26 at $407 (RepairPal). Year by year, the RAV4’s advantage is narrow: its best years are 2013 and 2016 at 85/100, against the Outback’s best, 2019 at 80/100. The bad years separate them: the RAV4’s worst year, 2019, scores 66/100, while the Outback’s 2013–2014 carry oil and CVT faults that cost $3,000–$5,000 outside warranty. The Outback’s counter is standard all-wheel drive on every year and a 22.3% chance of reaching 250,000 miles (iSeeCars). See Best Used Midsize SUVs for the size contrast — the Outback is a wagon/SUV crossover alternative, not a three-row SUV.
Used Outback Pre-Purchase Checklist and Final Verdict
See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist. For an Outback, add:
- Oil history on 2011–2015 cars: service records and piston-ring proof.
- CVT on 2013–2014 cars: shudder or slipping; confirm the 10-year / 100,000-mile extension by VIN (OrganizerTone).
- Head gasket on 2005–2012 cars: check for weeping around 100,000 miles.
- Battery drain on 2015–2021 cars: DCM sleep fault fixed? Get a parasitic-draw test.
- Windshield on 2018–2022 cars: cracks and replacements; does the Powell 8-year / 100,000-mile cover still apply?
- Recalls on 2019–2020 cars: confirm the fuel-pump and drive-chain recalls are closed on the VIN.
- Infotainment on 2018–2021 cars: test for delamination, ghost touches and freezing.
Final verdict: buy a 2023–2024 Outback, ideally a 2024. A 2016–2017 or a 2019 with its recalls closed is the best-value buy. Avoid 2010–2014 and 2020 outright.
Outback Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most
Is a 2019 Outback a good buy if it has the most complaints of any year?
Yes, with checks — mostly electrical complaints, a mature powertrain, and fuel-pump recalls fixed free.
Which Outback year is the single best pick?
The 2024 — AutoReliabilityIndex’s best-scoring year, no recalls, 69 complaints.
Should I avoid every 2013–2014 Outback?
As a blind buy, yes — defective piston rings and CVT failures, with the warranty extension now expired.
Does the battery drain problem affect all 2018–2021 Outbacks?
No — it is a DCM sleep fault, not a bad battery. Ask whether it was fixed and get a parasitic-draw test.
Is the 2025 Outback reliable?
Too early to judge — no recalls, 43 complaints on AutoReliabilityIndex, but no long-term data yet.
Sources
- CarsCounsel: Best and Worst Subaru Outback Years — https://carscounsel.com/subaru-outback-years-to-avoid/
- CarGurus: Subaru Outback Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy — https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/subaru-outback-buying-guide
- AutoReliabilityIndex: Subaru Outback Reliability by Year — https://autoreliabilityindex.com/subaru/outback
- KnowledgeMentors: Subaru Outback Years to Avoid When Shopping Used — https://knowledgementors.com/m-auto/afs/default/rsoc/0aa7eb7d-f7eb-4c1d-a210-41a628b4a4c3/subaru-outback-years-to-avoid-when-shopping-used?channel=Ch_58795
- TheHealthyAttitude: Subaru Outback Years to Avoid and the Model Years Worth Buying — https://thehealthyattitude.com/m-auto/afs/default/rsoc/c37b927c-30b0-49d0-9c8b-5722768b4d02/subaru-outback-years-to-avoid-and-the-model-years-worth-buying?channel=Ch_16911
- TheHealthyAttitude: Which Subaru Outback Model Years Hold Up Best — https://thehealthyattitude.com/m-auto/afs/default/rsoc/fa6f2921-1b15-48b6-9d77-2d6e82a261fc/which-subaru-outback-model-years-hold-up-best?channel=Ch_10180
- CarBuzz: Subaru Outback Years To Buy, And Years To Avoid — https://carbuzz.com/best-years-for-subaru-outback/
- CarBuzz: Subaru Outback Problems Most Commonly Reported By Owners Over Its Lifespan — https://carbuzz.com/subaru-outback-problems-and-reliability-over-its-lifespan/
- CarBuzz: Best Subaru Outback Model Years For Reliability — https://carbuzz.com/best-subaru-outback-model-years-for-reliability/
- RepairPal: Subaru Outback Reliability Rating — https://repairpal.com/reliability/subaru/outback
- RepairPal: Subaru Outback vs Toyota RAV4 — https://repairpal.com/cars/compare/toyota-rav4-vs-subaru-outback
- RepairPal: Subaru Outback vs Honda CR-V — https://repairpal.com/cars/compare/subaru-outback-vs-honda-cr-v
- NHTSA: Recalls and complaints by model year — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- J.D. Power: Outback Quality & Reliability scores by year (via CarBuzz) — https://www.jdpower.com/cars/subaru/outback
- iSeeCars: Subaru Outback Reliability — https://www.iseecars.com/car/subaru-outback/reliability
- CarComplaints: Subaru Outback complaints by year (via AutoReliabilityIndex and CarBuzz) — https://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/
- Torque News: New Subaru Outback XT 2.4L Turbo Vs. Discontinued 3.6L Engine — https://www.torquenews.com/1084/new-subaru-outback-xt-24l-turbo-vs-discontinued-36l-engine
- Powell v. Subaru of America, Inc. (windshield class action, D.N.J. 2024) — https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-jersey/njdce/1:2019cv19114/419228/155/
- In re Subaru Battery Drain Prod. Liab. Litig. (settlement, D.N.J. 2022) — https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.njd.430503/gov.uscourts.njd.430503.72.1.pdf
- CarLifespanCheck: Subaru Outback Reliability by Year (2013–2014 outlier position) — https://www.carlifespancheck.com/blog/subaru-outback-reliability-by-year
- Consumer Reports: Owner ratings and reliability (via CarGurus) — https://www.consumerreports.org/
Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Best Used SUVs, Best Used Midsize SUVs, Used Car Buying Guide, Toyota RAV4 Reliability, Honda CR-V Reliability.
