By Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer. Published 14 November 2026. Research-based: published data and NHTSA records; MY Car Reviews did not test, drive, inspect or own a Highlander. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy.
Toyota Highlander reliability by year is the simplest call in this series in one way and the trickiest in another: no Highlander year earns a blanket “avoid”, yet one transmission decides whether a given car is a safe buy.
Toyota Highlander Reliability by Year: The Shortlist
J.D. Power figures via TopSpeed; complaint counts via CarMerit.
| Year | Published record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | 209 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2014 | 81/100 J.D. Power | Good, with checks |
| 2015 | 190 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2016 | 83/100; 115 complaints | Strong buy |
| 2017 | UA80 8-speed; 262 complaints | Avoid unless verified (gas V6) |
| 2018 | 84/100, yet a UA80 year | Avoid unless verified (gas V6) |
| 2019 | 467 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2020 | 84/100; 5 recalls | Strong buy (hybrid); inspect (gas) |
| 2021 | 483 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2022 | 82/100; ARI best year | Strong buy |
| 2023 | 80/100; turbo | Good, with checks |
| 2024 | 39 complaints | Good, with checks |
| 2025 | Too new to score | Too new to score |
Read This First: “Avoid” vs “Caution” — Why the Sources Split
CarMerit calls the 2017–2018 gas V6 “the clearest high-risk choices” and says to avoid one “when transmission history cannot be verified”. ToyoLand insists no year earns a blanket avoid, because the UA80 fault is “checkable on the specific car”. This guide follows CarMerit: the risk attaches to a powertrain and a VIN.
The 2008 shows why scores alone mislead: TopSpeed ranks it the most reliable Highlander ever at 86/100, yet CarMerit flags its VVT-i oil-hose campaign and oil-cooler pipe leakage. Judge 2008 on its campaign paperwork, not its score.
Highlander Generations and Powertrains: A Map Before the Year-by-Year
Four generations matter (ToyoLand): 2001–2007, XU40 2008–2013, XU50 2014–2019, XU70 2020–present. The 2026 is too new to rank.
The 3.5-litre V6 ran through 2022 — 270 hp in 2014–2016, 295 hp from the 2017 facelift (CarCaseFile) — with older automatics, then the UA80 8-speed from 2017. The hybrid used a V6-based system in gen 3, then a 2.5-litre four making 243 hp combined from 2020 (ToyoLand). For 2023 the V6 gave way to a 2.4-litre turbo four, 265 hp and 310 lb-ft (ToyoLand), with a Direct Shift 8-speed.
Our Best Used Midsize SUVs guide names the Highlander Hybrid its best overall midsize pick.
Best Highlander Years to Buy: 2020–2022 Hybrid and 2014–2016 V6 Value
ToyoLand names 2020–2022 the best established modern used choice, especially the hybrid, and 2014–2016 the best older value. CarMerit agrees on the shape, with starting points 2013, 2016, 2019 and 2022, calling the 2016 “the most defensible all-around” gas starting point; AutoReliabilityIndex names the 2022 its best year.
The 2020–2022 hybrid is the standout — current-generation tech that sidesteps the UA80 — while the 2014–2016 V6 is the value pick: the proven 3.5-litre with the older automatics.
Gas V6 vs Hybrid: The Powertrain Choice That Matters Most
The hybrid avoids the UA80 entirely — it uses an eCVT, not the 8-speed (ToyoLand; OrganizerTone: hybrids are “completely unaffected by these specific issues”). CarCaseFile is blunt: “Buy the hybrid without hesitation.” EPA figures via CarMerit put a 2022 gas AWD at 20/27/23 mpg against 35/35/35 for the Hybrid AWD.
The hybrid is not fault-free. Certain 2020–2022 Hybrid AWD cars entered a Toyota support program for rear motor cable corrosion, which can cause warning indicators or a no-start (CarMerit). Certain 2014–2016 Hybrids fall under support program 24TE01 for brake-booster faults; primary coverage ended 31 March 2025 (CarMerit). For 2020-and-newer Hybrids, battery cover is 10 years or 150,000 miles, hybrid components 8 years or 100,000 miles (CarMerit) — verify by VIN.
The UA80 8-Speed Automatic (2017–2022 Gas V6): Whine, Hesitation, and the ZJC Support Program
The UA80 (UA80E front-drive, UA80F all-wheel-drive) arrived with the 2017 facelift and is the Highlander’s defining fault. Owners report a high-pitched whine, typically at 20–50 mph (OrganizerTone), gear hunting, rough downshifts and torque-converter shudder, with replacement at 20,000–60,000 miles (OrganizerTone). CarCaseFile puts the bill at $2,500–$9,000 and notes a class-action lawsuit covering 2017-onward Highlanders.
Toyota’s Customer Support Program ZJC covers certain 2017–2018 vehicles, extending transmission cover to 10 years from the in-service date for a specific defect: a washer tab meant to stop a nut loosening inside the transmission may not have been bent sufficiently during assembly (ToyoLand). Toyota also issued bulletins, including T-SB-0160-18, recalibrating shift logic (ToyoLand; OrganizerTone). A support program plus bulletins — not a safety recall. For 2020–2022 gas V6 cars the pattern is owner-reported and litigated, with no manufacturer program (ToyoLand).
The Proven Pairing: 2014–2016 V6 With the 6-Speed Automatic
The 2014–2016 cars are the safe harbour: the 3.5-litre V6 with the older automatics, before the 8-speed arrived (ToyoLand). The 2016 is the pick of the three — 83/100 J.D. Power (TopSpeed), 115 NHTSA complaints, fewest in gen 3 (CarMerit). Confirm two 2014 recalls closed: fuel-delivery pipe (14V576000) and second-row seat track (14V274000) (CarMerit).
The 2023 Switch: 2.4L Turbo Four — Early Evidence and the ECU Reflash
For 2023 Toyota replaced the 3.5-litre V6 with the 2.4-litre turbo four (T24A-FTS), 265 hp and 310 lb-ft — 30 fewer horsepower than the V6 but more torque at everyday speeds (ToyoLand). It pairs with an 8-speed Direct Shift automatic, a newer combination that should not be lumped in with the earlier V6’s transmission history; ZJC does not apply (ToyoLand).
Early 2023 builds need one fix: hesitation and surging, a bucking response most noticeable around town, fixed by the ECU reflash in T-SB-0087-23 (CarCaseFile). Beyond that the turbo has shown no widespread failures yet (CarCaseFile). Toyota lists spark-plug replacement at 40,000 miles or 48 months, required under the emissions-control warranty (CarMerit).
The 2008 V6 Warning: VVT-i Oil Hose and Oil-Cooler Pipe Campaigns
The 2008 launched the second generation and carries the model’s most complicated older-year story: a limited service campaign for the VVT-i oil supply hose on certain 2008 V6 Highlanders — the rubber portion could degrade and leak oil — plus an engine oil-cooler pipe warranty enhancement covering certain 2008–2011 Highlanders and certain 2011 Hybrids (CarMerit).
A 2008 V6 needs two answers: was it eligible for the VVT-i hose campaign and was the work done, and is the oil-cooler pipe dry or is there documented repair history (CarMerit)? Avoid the car when campaign status cannot be established or leakage is active. Consumer Reports lists 13 NHTSA recall campaigns for the 2008 (ToyoLand); TopSpeed counts 11. The score is not the verdict — the paperwork is.
Recalls to Verify by VIN: Fuel Pump, Seat-Back, and Safety Campaigns
Recall exposure is VIN-specific. Confirm these closed:
- Fuel pump: certain 2018–2019 Highlanders under NHTSA 20V-012 (January 2020), ~375,850 vehicles built November 2017–July 2019; expansion 20V-682 added certain 2017 cars (ToyoLand). Separate 2020 campaign 20V-162 covers fuel-supply programming (CarMerit; CarCaseFile).
- Second-row seat backs: campaign 26V-128 (March 2026), 550,007 Highlanders and Highlander Hybrids from 2021–2024 — recliners that may not latch. Free fix; owner letters from 20 April 2026 (CarCaseFile).
- 2020 safety software: VSC software recall 22V-239 and occupant-classification sensor recall 23V-865 (CarCaseFile).
- 2023–2025 screens and belts: blank gauge-cluster recall 25V-595 and back-up camera freeze recall 25V-744 (part of a 1,000,000+ vehicle Toyota/Lexus recall), plus third-row centre belt anchor recall 25V-872 for 2024–2025 (CarCaseFile).
- 2014: fuel-delivery pipe 14V576000 and second-row seat track 14V274000 (CarMerit).
The Grand Highlander is a separate model with its own record (CarCaseFile).
How Long Does a Highlander Last, and What Does It Cost to Own?
iSeeCars’ analysis of over 300 million vehicles puts the average Highlander lifespan at 184,926 miles, about 14.3 years, with a 40.1% chance of reaching 200,000 miles and a 7.8 out of 10 reliability rating. The Hybrid goes further: 198,404 miles, about 15.4 years, a 49.4% chance of 200,000 miles and an 8.0 rating.
RepairPal rates it 4.0 out of 5.0, 7th out of 26 midsize SUVs, at $489 a year — against $573 for the average midsize SUV and $652 for all vehicles — The Highlander also appears in our Best Used SUVs guide.
Highlander vs RAV4 and CR-V: Which Toyota SUV Holds Up Best?
The Highlander’s rivals are the cars in our Toyota RAV4 Reliability and Honda CR-V Reliability guides. On RepairPal’s headline numbers the three are close: the Highlander 4.0 out of 5.0, 7th of 26 midsize SUVs at $489 a year; the RAV4 4.0, 3rd of 26 at $429; the CR-V 4.5, 2nd of 26 at $407 (RepairPal). The RAV4’s best years are 2013 and 2016 at 85/100 against the Highlander’s best, the 2008 at 86/100 — but the 2008’s score comes with the oil-line campaigns above, while the RAV4’s worst year, 2019, scores 66/100.
Used Highlander Pre-Purchase Checklist: The Cold-and-Warm Test Drive
See our Used Car Buying Guide for the full checklist; add these Highlander checks:
- Drive a gas V6 cold AND warm, radio off: whine at 20–50 mph, harsh 2–3 shifts, light-throttle shudder.
- ZJC eligibility (2017–2018 gas) and serial-number check (2021 gas): dealer check of VIN, in-service date and remaining cover.
- Fuel-pump recall closed on 2017–2019 cars; fuel-supply programming done on 2020 cars.
- Hybrid checks: rear-motor cable program (2020–2022 AWD); brake-booster program 24TE01 (2014–2016); hybrid-system scan.
- Seat-back latch test on 2021–2024 cars: fold the second-row backs, then push to confirm they lock (26V-128).
- Early 2023 turbo: confirm T-SB-0087-23 reflash and spark plugs at 40,000 miles / 48 months.
- 2008–2011 oil leaks: VVT-i hose campaign status and a dry oil-cooler pipe.
Highlander Reliability Questions Buyers Ask Most
Is there any Highlander year to avoid completely?
No — no year earns a blanket avoid; the closest is an unverified 2017–2018 gas V6.
Which Highlander is the best buy if I want the lowest risk?
A 2020–2022 Hybrid, or a 2016 V6 on a tighter budget.
Does the 2018’s 84/100 J.D. Power score mean the transmission is fine?
No. The score and the transmission risk measure different things.
Is the hybrid battery a worry on a used Highlander Hybrid?
Less than the transmission is on a gas car.
Is a 2023 or newer turbo Highlander a safe used buy?
Promising but unproven: confirm the T-SB-0087-23 reflash on early 2023 builds.
Sources
- ToyoLand: Toyota Highlander Best and Worst Years (Used Buyer’s Guide) — https://toyoland.com/toyota-highlander-best-worst-years-buyer-guide/
- CarMerit: Toyota Highlander Years to Avoid and Best Years to Buy — https://carmerit.com/toyota-highlander-years-to-avoid/
- CarMerit: Toyota Highlander Reliability and Cost to Own Guide — https://carmerit.com/toyota-highlander-reliability/
- CarCaseFile: Toyota Highlander 2020–Present: Problems & Reliability — https://carcasefile.com/vehicles/toyota-highlander-2020-2024/
- TopSpeed: Best Toyota Highlander Model Years For Reliability — https://www.topspeed.com/best-toyota-highlander-model-years-reliability/
- Consumer Reports: Toyota Highlander / Highlander Hybrid model pages — https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/toyota/highlander/
- RepairPal: Toyota Highlander Reliability Rating — https://repairpal.com/reliability/toyota/highlander
- NHTSA: Recalls and complaints by model year — https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
- J.D. Power: Highlander Quality & Reliability scores by year (via TopSpeed) — https://www.jdpower.com/cars/toyota/highlander
- iSeeCars: Toyota Highlander Reliability — https://www.iseecars.com/car/toyota-highlander/reliability
- iSeeCars: Toyota Highlander Hybrid Reliability — https://www.iseecars.com/car/toyota-highlander-hybrid/reliability
- OrganizerTone: Toyota Highlander Transmission Problems by Year: Complete Guide — https://organizertone.com/en/toyota-highlander-transmission-problems-by-year-complete-guide-8252889/
- AutoReliabilityIndex: Toyota Highlander Reliability by Year — https://autoreliabilityindex.com/toyota/highlander
Author: Emily Turner — SUV & Truck Reviewer, MY Car Reviews. Research-based. See Review & Testing Methodology and Editorial Policy. Internal links: Best Used Midsize SUVs, Best Used SUVs, Used Car Buying Guide, Toyota RAV4 Reliability, Honda CR-V Reliability.
